The Pogues - Christmas In Glasgow
Part of a folio I had to send into University, an account of an event I'd seen in the last year.
The Pros You can't go wrong with a story that includes 'booze-soaked'. Seriously. I always love a story that has good description, even if it is a stereotypical indie band. The article feels like it could have been read out of a local 'scene' paper. Take that as a compliment :P
The Cons I fail to see anything wrong with the story to tell you the truth. It was well written in that if their were any typo's or grammatical I glanced right over them because I was enjoying the telling of your evening.
Final Thoughts Keep on drinking and do us drinking states and nations proud.
This review has not yet been rated.
The Pros Good review of ... something. Not quite sure who the hell you were talking about, but from the background information that was supplied I can imagine what they'd be like. But then again, who can't connect with a half-drunken band?
The Cons Even though a good picture was painted with the background info, more is always welcome. Some descriptions seemed a little vague, and could have been improved upon.
Final Thoughts Exceptional review. Seemed to be in a professional context, but appealed to me as not being a dull report.
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
The Pros First review on papertank, alright! And a good one to boot! I had been really pushing for people to do more reviews and informational pieces on TSS, and I hope more will happen at PT. I had no idea who any of the people you mentioned were, but you painted a perfect picture of who they were with background information and a detailed story of your personal experience with them. You put forth your opinion very well, and made this review your own with an added personal flavor.
The Cons I wish I could have gotten some more background information on the band you reviewed or the 'Christmas in Glasgow' event itself. Could have been a little longer, but I felt it did it's job without beating around the bush too much. And I probably would have found this more appealing if I knew who the people you were talking about were, but that's not your fault.
Final Thoughts Great Review, I hope to see a lot more where this came from. You did it just like how a magazine would. It felt professional AND personal. You told a story that I could picture in my head. I could envision all the hootin' and hollering and dancing around! Yeehaw!
4 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
Write a Review
Reviews double the weight of your vote and add up to increase your user rank .
You must be logged in to submit a review. Registering an account is quick, easy, and free.
Sign up now!
Opinion
Review
Music
Overall Stats
325 Views
13 Votes
Site Rankings
#6 for Score
#12 for Popularity
Honors Recieved Featured Article (6/5/08)
